Drained after church activities, or maybe you avoid them all-together? Overthinking conversations like it’s a spiritual discipline? Same. Welcome to The Introverted Apostle — where we recharge our social batteries, dodge small talk like a Navy SEAL at Church Service, and prove you don’t have to be loud to live your faith boldly. Episode 01 breaks down introversion, busts the myths and misconceptions, and remind you why the Body of Christ needs both the talkers and the thoughtful wall-holders. Welcome to church, please silence your phone...and your expectations of extroversion.

Guest: Dayna Schertler (of St. Ann's Catholic Church, Canyon)

Jesus went away to pray — introverts just kept the tradition alive! ✝️ Today’s episode focuses on how introversion shows up in church life and why quiet, reflective personalities are essential to building the Body of Christ. With our guest Carson Gerber, we talk introversion in church spaces, how quiet faith fits into a community-centered Church, and why God uses quiet people in powerful ways.

Guest: Carson Gerber (of First Methodist Church, Canyon)

Being part of a church shouldn’t require extroverted superpowers. In this episode, we explore social exhaustion, big church events, and the pressure introverts feel to constantly engage. Our guest John Reeves helps us name the struggle and rethink what “being involved” really means — reminding us that quiet faith still counts. If church life feels loud but your faith is quiet, this one’s for you. 

Guest: John Reeves (of St. Mary's Catholic Cathedral, Amarillo)

Introvert + Apostle = Christian paradox unlocked. Father Taylor Elzner explains how silence fuels mission, why labels aren’t boxes, and how to stop “communion to escape” and start living grace outward. Grace doesn’t delete your introversion — it perfects it! Introverts aren’t anti-social — we just need better WiFi with Heaven before mingling. This episode is introverted...but we make sure it is apostolic.  

Guest: Father Taylor Elzner (of Our Lady of Guadalupe Catholic Church, Amarillo)

Doosterhaus. Doisterhaus. Dusterhaus. However you pronounce it, Davlyn brought wisdom. Less noise and more depth in this week's episode, Davlyn Duesterhaus unpacks introvert survival tips: start small, know your boundaries, make eye contact (occasionally), and why wholeness takes both introverts and extroverts. It’s not either/or...it’s both/and. Take a deep breath and say, “Okay, God, here we go!” ⛪ BONUS: We attempt to pronounce her name correctly. 

Guest: Davlyn Duesterhaus (of St. Mary's Catholic Cathedral, Amarillo)

If starting a conversation at church feels like a leap of faith...you’re not alone. You know the moment — you lock eyes with someone after church, and suddenly you’re spiritually obligated to say something. Panic sets in, and now you’re deeply invested in the nearest exit sign. “What do I say?” “Is this weird?” “Do I abort mission?” This week on The Introverted Apostle, we’re diving into the art of starting conversations without overthinking yourself into silence...moving past the awkward and into authentic connection, one small, brave step at a time. And yes...we’re laughing our way through it, because let’s be honest — we’ve all been there.  

Guests: Becky Warren (of Harvest Connexion Church, Amarillo) & Dr. Teresa Baker (of St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Church, Amarillo)

Ever tried serving at church and thought, “This isn’t my ministry...or my personality”? Deacon Tino Frausto proves you can go from “I’ll just help behind the scenes” to proclaiming the Gospel — one slightly uncomfortable “yes” at a time. We dive into introverts in ministry, finding your fit without forcing it, and why God loves working through the people who'd rather not be the center of attention. A funny, honest, and encouraging convo about growth, community, and trusting God when He nudges you out of your comfort zone. Everyone has a seat at this table! 

Guest: Deacon Tino Frausto (of Our Lady of Guadalupe Catholic Church, Amarillo)

Church guilt got you saying yes to everything? Boundaries aren’t a lack of faith — they’re a sign of maturity. Father Tony drops wisdom on over-commitment, burnout, and the pressure to do it all. This episode dives into boundaries, spiritual gifts, and choosing the right yes instead of every yes. If you’ve ever felt like saying no means letting God down, this episode will flip that mindset. Freedom starts with knowing your limits. God called you...just not to everything. Sometimes the holiest thing you can say is “no.” 

Guest: Father Tony Neusch (of St. Anthony of Padua Catholic Church, Dalhart)

What if the most powerful thing you do today is sit down with one person and really listen? This episode dives into the power of one-on-one connections, where authenticity beats small talk and listening becomes a superpower...conversations go deeper, listening gets intentional, and “How’s your soul?” actually means something. From asking better questions to building lasting friendships, it’s all about going deeper with fewer people. No crowds, no pressure — just presence. Because one real connection is worth more than a hundred surface ones.

Guest: Charity Wilson (of Hillside Christian Church, Amarillo)

“Meet and greet time” during church? For introverts, that may qualify as spiritual warfare. This week, we dive into how churches can better support introverts without treating them like broken extroverts. What if the quiet person in the back row is one of the most gifted people in your church? We unpack how churches can better understand introverts, create healthier ministry environments, and help everyone feel seen, valued, and welcome in the Body of Christ. Plus, Father Alvin and Pastor Jeff bring plenty of humor, wisdom, and painfully relatable church moments. From “introvert recharge rooms” to cinnamon roll ministry, this episode proves there’s room in the Church for every personality God created. 

Guests: Jeff Marcoe (of First Nazarene Church, Amarillo) & Father Alvin Tshuma (of St. Mary's Catholic Church, Umbarger)

Breaking News: introverts didn’t accidentally wander into Christianity...they’re all over the Bible! Moses hated public speaking. Elijah found God in the still small voice. St. Joseph said...well...basically nothing. And Jesus ghosted the crowds for prayer time. Maybe introverts have been in the Bible all along. Join us as we explore what Scripture says about quiet strength, holy solitude, and why burnout might just need a little more Mary and less Martha. Sometimes the holiest thing you can do is turn off the car radio and sit in silence...because God often skips the fireworks and speaks in a whisper. 

Guest: Joshua Correa (of St. Mary's Catholic Cathedral, Amarillo)